Showing posts with label Toll. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Toll. Show all posts

Friday, 22 August 2008

KESAS

It came to my attention that our force expenditure issue is far from a positive solution. I posted fact and figures about Plus and how there should be no reason for any excuses to not to reduce the toll. Today’s paper showing LDP, Kesas and NPE profitability and none of it been passed on to public.

Let us first look on the KESAS, which claimed to earn RM5.61 billions profit.

Shareholders:
PKNS (30%)
GAMUDA (30%)
AMDB (Arab Malaysian) (20%)
PNB (Permodalan Nasional Berhad) (20%)

Combined state (PKNS) and central (PNB) say to the company decision, 50% right already given to government combined. This has not been thoroughly deep for GLC equity in AMDB and GAMUDA. Combine both direct and indirect equity holding, I am sure government have the veto decision of the KESAS well being.

What possibly could justify the RM 2.20 per tollbooth charges?
R&R – I am sure KESAS is charging the stall/ shop keepers with rent
Toilet – how much does it need to facilitate and maintain toilet per R&R
Emergency line – it wouldn’t cost that much.
No traffic jam – is it?

The toll charges will keep escalating with the concession deal. The end of it is farsighted, and the 28 years 9 month concession would end on late 2021. Knowing our present government trend, like we observe on PUSPAKOM 15 years extension deal, government would hardly want to loose any revenue that each time mysteriously missing Malaysian public pocket.

There is no reason for optimistic thinking. The concession deal needs to be looked at immediately. Charges need to be reasonable and tax money should not be paid to the concessionaire on profit loss recovery.

Friday, 11 July 2008

A bit of facts on PLUS

Amongst the biggest shareholders for PLUS:
UEM (indirectly, Khazanah): 40%
Khazanah: 24%
EPF: 10%
ASB: 4%

As it stand on 2007 financial report:
Toll collection: RM 1.82 billions
Profit before tax: RM 1.31 billions (72% of toll revenue)
Liabilities: RM 10 billions
Asset: RM 15.9 billions
Tax exemption: RM 400 millions

PLUS have to publish this because they are a public listed company. The numbers speak for themselves.

Agreement between PLUS and G’ment is G’ment to G’ment.
Toll charges is ridiculously high
EPF only gave out 5% dividend.
We been forced to feed Khazanah, EPF,… but return to us is insignificant
Further tax exemption on highly profitable organization taking out further public money to enrich government and their high pays corporate figures.
PLUS do not have nett liabilities instead nett asset worth 5 billions.
….

There will be talk about reviewing concession clauses and reducing toll price for consumers. Will there be further compensation from public fund to PLUS for profit loss? Will the charge truly reduced to benefit the public and country economic growth (imagine small business can emerge on substantial reduce on transportation cost).

We can’t help to ponder if the toll still necessary. Are we seeing Khazanah to collapse without toll collection and eventually crippled economy growth? Or will be seeing more economic growth since transportation is amongst the biggest private and SMI spent? What is the effect of charging RM 0.01 or less per km compare to RM 0.14 per km to PLUS, Khazanah, Malaysia, SMI, and public?

I am stating again and again about wealth distribution. Last year we are seeing 5% EPF dividend, 7% ASB, low increment for GLC and yet we are the main contributors to this organization profitability. This organization (government) in no loss business and making tonnes of money directly from our pocket. The money does not circulated back to our wealth growth but disappear elsewhere.

We are paying a lot to own a car because of Proton (GLC), pay high fuel price because of Petronas want to export domestic output (GLC), high toll because of PLUS (Khazanah, GLC),….. The minute I buy a car, I would pay about 10,000 on excise duty and tax go to government, pay 100 on a full tank that bulk of it go to Petronas profitability and government tax, pay RM 100 to make a visit to my parents to PLUS that is own by GLC, barely left with anything by month end and still have to pay yearly income tax, road tax, licence renewal, …
Who is helping whom??

Friday, 27 June 2008

Road Malaysia

What a ridiculous price to pay to own a car and commute. How could somebody idiotic mind led us to this rubbish system. The minute we bought ourselves a car (which is actually essential purchase) is the minute that we enslaved ourselves to this irrational systems. First, we have to pay RM900 at least to obtain a licence and RM 30 annual licence cost. Then, 140% is charged on excise duty on top of ‘declared’ total cost for the car in Malaysia. 10% sales tax on top of the grand total. Insurance which is ridiculously expensive comparative to the return (processing time to claim and re-valuation of the car during claims). Then, come road tax which government keen on reducing mostly to ignore necessity to build more PUBLIC road. Later, come the ridiculous fuel cost and tollbooth that are mostly impossible to avoid.

Yes, somebody made a mistake on the toll concession deal. 10% increases every 3 years plus government commitment to back every cent for losses made. Now there are ‘discussion’ between concessionaire and government on possibilities of reducing the toll. But in the press statement, the two main element of 10% increase and no-loss assurance was mentioned. I am not sure what sort of agreement would be concluded and if there actually rakyat’s money will not further wasted by government on making some individual wealthier.

Most likely, we would never rid of the stupid clauses that was agreed and endorsed by the empowered body before without the expense of our money to make sure some individual wealth growth not to be interfered. But, I am really sure that somebody in the office there would have some level of intelligent to use some other method. In business, supply and demand rules always applied. Each year, more than half million vehicle registered in Malaysia and the figure will keep increasing on exponential rate (due to low vehicle disposal rate). The more packed and jammed the highway, the more government have to pay the concessionaire with our money. Ironically, it is a trend now to put tollbooth on most of the new road developed. What had happened to public road development? Are we ignoring this development? What happened to all the charges that we paid? Only with alternative but reasonably fast route would enable us to have a choice to avoid this tollbooth and still arrived at destination and timely order. Aren’t that what out government should provide. Then the toll charges will not matter and they can charge any amount that they want and a single cent will not come out from our pocket. Demand will drop and supply demand rule will supersede the price and eventually will become more reasonable through time.

Personally, I don’t think government move on reducing the road tax as an incentive to reduce our burden was necessary. It was merely burdens that our government themselves intelligently created. I will not mind to pay the original amount providing that I have a free road to drive on. I want alternative free and quality road. I want government to stop awarding new road development to privatized concessionaire that will eventually and proudly build a tollbooth in the expense of our money anyway.

Summary:
1. Make good alternative public road.
2. Use transportation related revenue for transportation related development. Not to central government and spent at central government discretion
3. Review cost thoroughly to reduce over-payment to contractors
4. Stop confusing people with this road tax reduction bullsh*t
5. Stop awarding highway development that will eventually have more tollbooth
6. Sue those ‘intelligence’ that allow the concessionary deal sign-off. Shift government (rakyat’s) liability to personal liability.
7. Toll should be charged (if any) in cents not Ringgit. Charges should only cover cost of maintenance.
8. Review all the contract include R&R toilet cleaning contract. Somebody is sitting on sh* t load amount of money there.